It’s been said that all great literature boils down to one of two stories—a man takes a journey, or a stranger comes to town. While mystery writers have been successfully using both approaches for generations, there’s something undeniably alluring in the nature of a stranger: the uninvited guest, the unacquainted neighbor, the fish out of water.

No matter how or where they appear, strangers are walking mysteries, complete unknowns in once-familiar territories who disrupt our lives with unease and wonder. In the newest collection of stories by the Mystery Writers of America, each author weaves a fresh tale surrounding the eerie feeling that comes when a stranger enters our midst, featuring stories by prolific mystery writers such as Michael Connelly, Dean Koontz and Joe Hill.

I found the premise of this anthology to be really interesting, and in some cases creepy. Each story incorporates the idea of a stranger arriving and how that may shape the story. I did find a lot of the stories to be suspenseful or have satisfying twists, but as is the story with a lot of anthologies, there were some favorites and some not so much a favorite. That being said, I enjoyed seeing all the different ways the authors interpreted the premise and wove their stories around it.

Happy reading!